top of page
Search

Do Book Awards Matter?

  • schlesadv
  • Jan 22
  • 2 min read

Why book awards can matter

1. Credibility & Social Proof

  • An award signals quality to readers, booksellers, reviewers, and media.

  • Even lesser-known awards can reassure hesitant buyers.

  • “Award-winning author” is a powerful phrase in marketing copy.

Most useful for: debut authors, literary fiction, poetry, serious nonfiction.


2. Marketing & Visibility

  • Awards give you a reason to pitch media, libraries, festivals, and bookstores.

  • They can extend a book’s lifespan long after launch.

  • Award seals on covers and websites increase click-through and trust.

Reality check: Awards rarely create a bestseller on their own—but they amplify existing efforts.


3. Gatekeeper Access

Some doors open more easily with awards:

  • Literary festivals and speaking events

  • Academic adoption

  • Grants, fellowships, and residencies

  • Foreign rights and translation interest


4. Author Confidence & Career Building

  • Validation can matter psychologically—especially after years of work.

  • Awards accumulate over time and strengthen an author’s long-term brand.


Why awards often don’t matter much

1. Readers Don’t Buy Books Because of Awards

Most readers buy because of:

  • Genre expectations

  • Word of mouth

  • Reviews

  • A compelling premise or cover

Many top-selling books never win awards.

2. There Are Too Many Awards

  • Hundreds of awards exist, many with low prestige.

  • Some are pay-to-enter and have little industry recognition.

  • Winning an obscure award often has minimal impact.

3. Genre Fiction Relies Less on Awards

Thrillers, romance, sci-fi, fantasy, and self-help usually succeed through:

  • Series momentum

  • Reader loyalty

  • Amazon algorithms

  • Consistent output

Awards matter far less here than in literary fiction.


When awards matter most

Awards are most valuable if:

  • You write literary fiction or poetry

  • You want academic, cultural, or critical recognition

  • You’re building a speaking, teaching, or nonprofit mission

  • You want long-term prestige more than short-term sales


Publishing exceptional books of all genres since 2008

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
How Important is a Book's Cover?

A book’s cover is the  first sales pitch , whether that happens in a bookstore, on Amazon, or as a tiny thumbnail on a phone. Before a reader reads a single word of your blurb, the cover has already a

 
 
 
What Do I Need to Pitch My Book to a Movie Producer?

A  movie pitch deck  is a short, highly visual presentation—usually a PDF or slideshow—designed to  sell your film idea to producers, studios, financiers, or streaming platforms. Think of it as  the m

 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page